CO129-156 - Sir MacDonnell - 1872 [1-3] — Page 50

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Commanding Her Majesty's Troops.

China, absent from indisposition.

The Council meets this day at ... by special summons.

The Minutes of the Council held on the ... Instant, are read and Confirmed.

His Excellency, read two Letters, dated respectively the 18th, and 23rd Instant, from the Honorable Chief Justice Smale, applying for leave of absence on the ground of continuous and serious ill health. This application, His Excellency states, is supported by a Certificate, dated 18th December, from Dr. Duns, Acting Colonial Surgeon, of a very peculiar character; because, in points of fact, it amounted to this – that the Chief Justice's mental powers were so impaired that any attempt to discharge his judicial duties would be as certainly dangerous to himself, as injurious to the Public interests, – and a source of general scandal.

His Excellency adds, that in a personal interview with Dr. Duns that morning, he had ascertained that Mr. Smale's case was even more decidedly serious than might perhaps be gathered from the Medical Certificate as the latter had, of course, to be seen.

Edit History

2026-05-20 14:28:47 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Commanding Her Majesty's Troops. China, absent from indisposition. The Council meets this day at ... by special summons. The Minutes of the Council held on the ... Instant, are read and Confirmed. His Excellency, read two Letters, dated respectively the 18th, and 23rd Instant, from the Honorable Chief Justice Smale, applying for leave of absence on the ground of continuous and serious ill health. This application, His Excellency states, is supported by a Certificate, dated 18th December, from Dr. Duns, Acting Colonial Surgeon, of a very peculiar character; because, in points of fact, it amounted to this that the Chief Justice's mental powers were so impaired that any attempt to discharge his judicial duties would be as certainly dangerous to himself, as injurious to the Public interests, and a source of general scandal. His Excellency adds, that in a personal interview with Dr. Duns that morning, he had ascertained that Mr. Smale's case was even more decidedly serious than might perhaps be gathered from the Medical Certificate as the latter had, of course, to be seen.
Baseline (Original)
19 "Commanding Her Majesty' Troops. China, absent from indisposition. in "The Cormeil meets this day at From by special ummons. The Minnes of the Connoil held on the Quá Instanú, are reax and Confirmed. "His Excellency, rexa's tws Lecters, dated respectively the 18th, and 23tt Instant, from the Honorable Chief Justice Suck, applying for leave of absence on the groused of continuous and serious ill health. This application, this Excelleng states, is supported by a Certificate, dated 18th December, from Dr Dos, 0.1.0. MD 33537 ann 3449. 0.5.0.3330. "Acting Colonise Surgeon, of a very peculiar characur; because, in points of fact, it amonneed to this that the chief Justices mental powers were so impaired his part that any attempe to discharge his judiciai duties would be as artrinly dangerous to himself, as injurious to the Public interests, and scandal. that in a source of general Bris Excellency adás, personal interview with It Don's that morning, he had ascertained that Mr Smale's Case pas even mux decidedly serious than might perhaps be gathered from the Medical Certificut as the latter had of. course to be seen.
2026-05-20 14:28:47 · Baseline
View content

19

"Commanding Her Majesty' Troops.

China, absent from indisposition.

in

"The Cormeil meets this day at From

by special

ummons.

The Minnes of the Connoil held on the Quá Instanú, are reax and Confirmed.

"His Excellency, rexa's tws Lecters, dated

respectively the 18th, and 23tt Instant, from the Honorable Chief Justice Suck, applying for leave of absence on the groused of continuous and serious ill health. This

application, this Excelleng

states, is supported by a Certificate, dated 18th December, from Dr Dos,

0.1.0. MD 33537 ann 3449.

0.5.0.3330.

"Acting Colonise Surgeon, of a very peculiar characur; because, in points

of fact, it amonneed to this that the chief Justices mental powers

were so impaired

his

part

that

any attempe to discharge his judiciai

duties would be as

artrinly dangerous

to himself, as injurious to the Public

interests, – and

scandal.

that in a

source of general

Bris Excellency adás,

personal interview

with It Don's that morning, he

had ascertained that Mr Smale's

Case

pas even

mux

decidedly serious

than might perhaps be gathered

from the Medical Certificut

as

the

latter had of.

course to be

seen.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.